Back to previous
Newer version available

There is a newer version of this publication available:
Debt Advice Handbook Scotland 1st ed - with new material

What is a trust deed
A trust deed is a voluntary, legally binding agreement between a client and their creditors, operated by and through an insolvency practitioner.
It is insolvency in the wider sense, but not bankruptcy as such. It is governed in much the same way and there are more similarities than differences, as many of the same rules apply across all insolvency solutions.
A trust deed can be unprotected or obtain protected status and become a protected trust deed (PTD).
Under a PTD, creditors cannot pursue the debts owed to them, giving the client the same protection from creditors as bankruptcy. This is the main reason to have the trust deed protected. A PTD is suitable for a client that cannot pay their debts within a reasonable timescale and wishes to exclude the family home, although that is not always possible.
Voluntary trust deeds for creditors are covered in Part 14 of the Bankruptcy (Scotland) Act 2016.
All the forms used in a PTD can be found at legislation.gov.1legislation.gov.uk/sdsi/2016/9780111033173/schedule
Some advantages of a protected trust deed
It is not bankruptcy and might be more useful to a client whose job excludes them from being bankrupt.
Your client can discuss the terms of the trust deed and come to an agreement with the trustee before they sign. This can be useful in working out how disposable income is to be assessed, how assets are to be realised and specifically if the family home is to be excluded.
The trustee deals with all creditor correspondence and queries.
All interest and charges on the debts are frozen on the date the trust deed is signed.
Your client makes one affordable monthly payment, normally for 48 months.
Once the trust deed is given protected status, no further action can be taken against the client by their creditors.
After completion of the terms of the trust deed, the client is discharged from their debts and all included remaining debt will be written off.
Some disadvantages of a protected trust deed
Your client must pay contributions towards their debts for at least 48 months.
Having a trust deed will affect your client’s credit rating for six years from the date the trust deed is signed.
Joint trust deeds are not possible.
If the client’s situation changes, there is no zero contribution available (as there is in bankruptcy). Therefore, it may last longer than 48 months.
The creditors may not agree to the terms and the trust deed may not gain protected status, and the client may have to look at bankruptcy as a result.
Secured creditors may still take action to take possession of a debtor’s home if they fall behind with mortgage payments.
If any new debts are taken on after a trust deed is signed, the debtor is not protected from legal action by these new creditors. Servicing new debts may affect the debtor’s ability to maintain the agreed monthly contributions.
Role of the AiB
While trust deeds are a voluntary agreement between the client and their creditors, the AiB acts as a regulator, supervising the performance of trustees, and trust deeds cannot gain protected status without the consent of the AiB.
Who can sign a trust deed
To be able to sign a trust deed and have it protected, the client must be:1s164(1) B(S)A 2016
    a living individual; or
    a partnership; or
    a limited partnership; or
    a trust; or
    a corporate body; or
    an unincorporated body.
Joint trust deeds are not allowed.
The client must not:2s164(2) B(S)A 2016
    be someone whose estate has been sequestrated if the trustee in the sequestration has not been discharged;
    be a limited company;
    have unsecured debts under £5,000 (including interest) at the date the trust deed is granted.
 
1     s164(1) B(S)A 2016 »
2     s164(2) B(S)A 2016 »
Partnerships
Partnership trust deeds are possible. In such cases, each partner, plus the partnership as a whole, needs to sign a trust deed, it cannot all be rolled into one.
Take advice from an insolvency practitioner if this situation arises.
Consequences
The main consequence of signing a trust deed is if it does not gain protected status because of creditor objections. In this case, the client will most likely need to look at sequestration as an option. This could be particularly difficult if the client wants to exclude their family home from the trust deed as this will not be possible in sequestration.
Signing a trust deed also constitutes apparent insolvency and creditors can use this to bankrupt the client. They have a set period of five weeks in the process in which they can do this.1s177(1)(a) B(S)A 2016
The trust deed has an effect on the client’s credit file and is registered for six years after the date of signing.
It may also have an effect on your client’s employment, and you should check this is not the case before you make a recommendation.
 
1     s177(1)(a) B(S)A 2016 »
Fees
There are no upfront fees to enter into a trust deed, although the client must be able to make a contribution or realise assets to pay fees and a return to the creditors.
The trustee has a fixed fee for a trust deed, plus costs and outlays. The trustee takes their fees from contributions and realisation of any assets. They also receive a percentage of all contributions or of asset realisation.1s183 B(S)A 2016
 
1     s183 B(S)A 2016 »
Included and excluded debts
All debts muat be included, but all may not discharge (ie, student loans).1s184 B(S)A 2016
The same general rules apply as for bankruptcy (see here).
 
1     s184 B(S)A 2016 »